A recent monologue from Tucker Carlson’s Fox News program is blowing up the right-wing blogosphere, and understandably so. Carlson has been a vocal critic of the neoliberal deification of economic efficiency at all costs. I used to be a member of this cult, until the candidacy of Donald Trump (and lived experience) knocked the idealistic scales from my eyes.
Normally, it bugs me when people send me video clips to watch. If they’re cutesy videos of the variety that drive clicks—think cats playing piano, or Goth versions of Christmas songs—I usually ignore them, no matter how hyped they are. That’s not some virtue on my part; I just don’t want to take the time to watch them, especially on a cell phone (a pet peeve: someone making me watch a video on their cell phone; I will refuse).
That said, I’m indulging in some hypocrisy: you must watch this video as soon as you’re able.
For those of you that don’t want to take the time, here are some highlights:
- Elites care only about maximizing economic efficiency, regardless of the human costs to individuals, families, and communities
- That lust for efficiency drives income inequality, particularly benefiting the technology sector/Silicon Valley
- “We are ruled by mercenaries, who feel no long-term obligation to the people they rule”—a key idea; I’ve read a similar analysis from controversial blogger Z-Man, in which he argues that leaders in a democracy are, inherently, renters rather than owners, and therefore are heavily tempted towards asset-stripping while in office, rather than building and maintaining a nation: http://thezman.com/wordpress/?p=15929
- Because of the hollowing out of American manufacturing and declining wages (again, due in part to the quest for efficiency), men struggle to find employment or to improve their wages
- Because of that, rural parts of the country are dominated increasingly by healthcare and education, female-dominated fields
- While better wages for women is fine, Carlson claims that—whether or not they should—women are less likely to marry men who earn less than them, therefore—
- Marriage rates are declining, leading to all sorts of societal problems: out-of-wedlock births; listless, professionally-personally-sexually-unfulfilled men; rising drug abuse (due in part, too, to declining wages and unemployment—men find great meaning from work), etc.
These are just some of the most interesting insights, but Carlson sums up in fifteen minutes what would take a legion of hack bloggers like me hours or weeks to explain.
Again, I urge you to watch this video: https://video.foxnews.com/v/5985464569001/?playlist_id=5198073478001#sp=show-clips
[…] Tucker Carlson’s Diagnosis […]
LikeLike
[…] (metaphorically) the country has woken up to the chumpitude our elites foisted on us for so long. Tucker Carlson’s monologue diagnoses this malady thoroughly, as you and I have both written about. (Hyperlink […]
LikeLike
[…] the risk of breaking my general injunction against telling people to watch lengthy videos twice in one month, I’d refer you to this excellent explanation from McInnes […]
LikeLike
[…] if you haven’t yet gotten around to it, check out Tucker Carlson’s 3 January 2019 monologue (a nice birthday present for yours […]
LikeLike
[…] of the Left—have convinced me that, as wonderful as free markets are, we’ve tended to sacrifice real lives and communities in exchange for cheap plastic junk. I’ve also considerably altered my views on immigration; at this point, I think America […]
LikeLike
[…] not merely cogs in faceless corporate machines. In reading Ingram’s review, I heard echoes of Tucker Carlson’s recent on-air musings, particularly the idea that efficiency is not a god to be worshipped blindly, and that capitalism […]
LikeLike
[…] I’m not usually one to insist you watch a video, but Z-Man’s video is the best comprehensive analysis I’ve seen or read about the Democratic field so far. In a no-nonsense, quite politically-incorrect way, Z-Man breaks the field down into the competing “tribes” of the Democrats, such as the “Festive Tribe” (Hispanics), the Angry Woman Tribe, etc. […]
LikeLike
[…] about the rise in economic nationalism before, including a detailed case study from Breitbart. Tucker Carlson’s 3 January 2019 monologue is probably the best defense of an “American First” agenda I’ve ever […]
LikeLike
[…] It just goes to show that you can’t cuck the Tuck. Hopefully Fox News backs up their host. It’s also interesting seeing how based Tucker Carlson as far back as 2006, which suggests he’s sincere in his populist peccadilloes. […]
LikeLike
[…] The implication from neoliberal and libertarian types is that, at best, that desire is unrealistic; at worst, it’s bad: your loyalty should only be to efficiency! Efficiency is morality! While I love efficiency as much as the next cog, efficiency-for-its-own-sake is not and should not be our god. […]
LikeLike
[…] “Tucker Carlson’s Diagnosis” – one of the posts from the early days of The Streak ’19, it was also a rare […]
LikeLike
[…] “Tucker Carlson’s Diagnosis” – Fox News host Tucker Carlson eloquently and forcefully expressed some of the ideas implied in the previous bullet point in a powerful monologue back in January 2019. Carlson has become a major paleoconservative voice, one that offers a much-needed counterbalance to the capitalism-as-highest-good mentality dominant in the Republican Party. […]
LikeLike
[…] “Tucker Carlson’s Diagnosis” – one of the posts from the early days of The Streak ’19, it was also a rare video post […]
LikeLike
[…] I’ve got two videos about the recent Democratic debates for you, one from the great Tucker Carlson, the other from YouTube personality RazörFist. Both sum up the lunacy, the recklessness, and the […]
LikeLike
[…] time in decades. Moribund wage growth, especially among working-class men, has created a whole host of social problems. Higher wages means more spending (and hopefully more saving, but don’t hold your […]
LikeLike
[…] of those critiques, capitalism remains the best system we’ve ever developed. I agree with Tucker Carlson that the economy is a tool, not an ends to itself, but if government interferes too much with the […]
LikeLike
[…] Carlson is the gift that keeps on giving. In a segment from last week, the populist-friendly television host offered up a winning strategy […]
LikeLike
[…] week’s TBT looks back to a piece I wrote in January 2019 that summarized a segment Tucker Carlson did on his wildly popular show. That segment really […]
LikeLike
[…] the gist of Z-Man’s post today, “Middle-Man Conservatism.” Tucker Carlson has similarly touched upon the woeful consequences of worshiping Efficiency-for-its-own-sake. […]
LikeLike
[…] mean our situations don’t suck here. We sacrificed social stability and family on the Altar of Efficiency, and now we have childless two-income couples scraping by instead of happy, child-filled families […]
LikeLike
[…] “Tucker Carlson’s Diagnosis” (and “TBT: Tucker Carlson’s Diagnosis“) – This post was about a monologue Tucker gave in early 2019 (I think the monologue was actually delivered on my birthday). That monologue really opened my eyes to the folly of pursuing economic efficiency at all costs. A key quote from The Tuck: “We are ruled by mercenaries, who feel no long-term obligation to the people they rule.” […]
LikeLike